Houston Chronicle
November 7, 1996

Humble family sues Entex alleging harm by chemicals
By George Flynn
A Humble family has sued Entex and other companies, alleging that the odorizing chemicals added to natural gas for safety are actually dangerous to humans.

Members of the Richard W. Royall family contend that they have been injured by continuing leaks of the additives from the Natural Gas Odorizing Inc. plant about 50 feet from their home. Defendants include the odorizing company, Entex and Houston Pipeline Co.

A spokeswoman for Entex denied the allegations and said the chemicals are harmless.

The Royall's attorney, John Tavormina, filed the lawsuit in state district court, seeking unspecified damages. He said other neighbors also are exposed to the hazard. "The important thing is to prevent this stuff from leaking in large quantities and causing more of these types of injuries," he said.

Tavormina says the problems stem from mercaptan and other odorizing chemicals added to natural gas, which is odorless, so people can smell it.

David Shoop, the safety manager, said the state Railroad Commission requires that the chemicals be added. He said no ill effects have been found in Entex employees and the chemical makers, who regularly work with the product.

The lawsuit says Richard Royall, 40, and his family moved in to their house in 1979 and began noticing leaks from the plant during the 1980s. Plaintiffs include his wife, Rebecca Royall, 36, and his children Adam Royall, 14, and Krystel Royall, 11.

They are suffering from bone and joint pain, acute headaches and other physical problems, the suit said. It also says family pets have been unable to reproduce.

Shoop said Entex had one service call for a leak at the plant about two months ago, and promptly made repairs without problems to the plant or to surrounding residents.